Commentary on Sections Costs and expenses
57.The Employment Tribunals Act 1996 authorises employment tribunal procedure regulations to provide for the award of costs or expenses (costs are known in Scotland as expenses). The regulations provide that where in the opinion of the tribunal a party has in bringing the proceedings, or a party or his/her representative has in conducting the proceedings, acted vexatiously, abusively, disruptively or otherwise unreasonably, then the tribunal shall consider whether to award costs against that party and may do so. Similarly, costs may be awarded where the bringing or conducting of the proceedings by a party has been misconceived (which includes having no reasonable prospect of success). The regulations do not give tribunals a general power to award costs against the losing party, in the absence of these factors. There will be no change to the circumstances in which the tribunal may award costs against such a party.
58.As far as the Employment Appeal Tribunal is concerned, the power in the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 to make rules dealing with costs and expenses is limited to cases where the proceedings were unnecessary, improper or vexatious or there has been unreasonable delay or other unreasonable conduct in bringing or conducting the proceedings.
59.In its consultation document ‘Routes to Resolution’, the Government suggested “all concerned - users, their representatives and the tribunals - must play their part in ensuring that time wasting is minimised.” Specifically, the document proposed giving the tribunals new powers to make orders for wasted costs against representatives are acting on a for profit basis; changing the presumption on costs; and allowing any costs awarded to include the time spent preparing the case. Currently employment tribunals cannot include in any award an amount to reflect time spent by a party preparing for the employment tribunal claim and there is no power to make an award directly against a representative, where his/her behaviour has been found inappropriate